---
title: "State Audit Faults Tennessee Hwy Patrol on Evidence Reviews"
url: https://www.herechattanooga.com/2026/11/19/tennessee-highway-patrol-audit-evidence-reviews-missed/
date: 2026-11-19T12:36:07-05:00
modified: 2026-11-19T12:36:07-05:00
author: "HERE City State Desk"
categories: ["Public Safety"]
site: "HEREChattanooga"
attribution: "HEREChattanooga"
---

# State Audit Faults Tennessee Hwy Patrol on Evidence Reviews

> NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Only about four in 10 of the evidence reviews the Tennessee Highway Patrol owed between the start of 2023 and the end of 2025 were done properly, according to a state Comptroller review of the agency that oversees the patrol, the Department of Safety and Homeland Security, released this week. Auditors counted

*Source: [HEREChattanooga](https://www.herechattanooga.com/2026/11/19/tennessee-highway-patrol-audit-evidence-reviews-missed/) — November 19, 2026 by HERE City State Desk*

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Only about four in 10 of the evidence reviews the Tennessee Highway Patrol owed between the start of 2023 and the end of 2025 were done properly, according to a state Comptroller review of the agency that oversees the patrol, the Department of Safety and Homeland Security, released this week.

Auditors counted 126 required reviews over that stretch. Troopers and staff never performed 40 of them, about 32%. Another 34, roughly 27%, were carried out but fell short of the agency rules, leaving 52 that met the standard.

## What went wrong

Most of the flawed reviews, 24 in all, lacked any record showing the reviewer had looked at the underlying case files. Four left noted discrepancies unexplained, four skipped required details such as the case number, the type of evidence or who did the check, one was handled by a person with no authority to do it, and one came in late.

The Comptroller traced much of the trouble to the patrol evidence manual, which scatters review requirements across several sections instead of laying them out in one place. Agency managers told auditors that staff were unsure whose job the reviews were. Some evidence custodians said they learned the work by shadowing coworkers or by trial and error, without formal instruction or written guidance on tasks such as running vehicle storage lots.

## DUI decisions under the microscope

The report, more than 100 pages long, also looked at how patrol leaders oversee the evidence troopers weigh before arresting or citing a driver for impaired driving, including whether probable cause was established first. A breath or blood result under the legal limit does not by itself mean an arrest lacked probable cause, since officers can rely on other signs of impairment.

## The agency response

Patrol management agreed with the findings. In its written response, the agency said it is rewriting its Evidence Manual with new standards, assigned responsibilities and formal training for custodians, and that district captains will be required to sign off that every evidence audit, inventory and review has been completed.
